By Ankur Banerjee and Stefanno Sulaiman
SINGAPORE/JAKARTA, Nov 17 (Reuters) – Indonesian markets have been flashing warning signs for most of the year, and a burst of political chaos has made the vulnerabilities in Southeast Asia’s largest economy and its battered currency harder for investors to ignore.
A one-time investor favourite, Indonesia is caught between political upheaval that has brought an increased security presence to the streets of Jakarta and a market rout as it faces losing its emerging-market status.
Indonesia is home to this year’s worst-performing major stock market in the world and a currency at record lows despite heavy central bank intervention. Borrowing costs hover near their highest since the COVID pandemic.
Cracks are appearing in the political sphere too. President Prabowo Subianto’s rift with his popular predecessor, Joko Widodo, has widened after Widodo’s son resigned as vice president.
And the president’s chief of staff and three senior police officials have been arrested on suspicion of involvement in the wiretapping of Prabowo. Reuters was unable to contact the accused officials or their legal representatives.
Thomas Pepinsky, professor of government at Cornell University, said the market concerns are “ultimately political risk”.
“There’s more political uncertainty about the next six months in Indonesia than any time I can remember in the past two decades,” he said.
UNCLEAR WHERE CRISES WILL LEAD
What began with a warning from index provider MSCI in January over free floats, opaque share ownership and coordinated trading behaviour has become a test of confidence in how Indonesia has been run since Prabowo took office in October 2024.
MSCI’s escalation in October to a more serious threat to relegate Indonesian stocks down two levels to standalone status has cast a deeper shadow over the $1.4 trillion economy.
The string of market and political blows has sparked memories of the Asian financial crisis in 1997-98, which ultimately toppled President Suharto, Prabowo’s former father-in-law, ending his three-decade rule.
Eve Warburton, senior lecturer at the Australian National University, said while there are echoes of 1998, it is “very unclear where these converging crises will lead”.
“What we do know is that Indonesia’s democracy is facing its most serious challenge since the transition from autocracy at the end of the 1990s.”
RUPIAH PINNED AT RECORD LOWS
The rupiah has acted as a pressure valve, dropping 14% in the two years since Prabowo came to power as investors fret about the cost of his programmes, their toll on hard-earned fiscal credibility as well as the central bank’s autonomy.
“The starting point for Indonesia is decent, but it is on a slippery slope,” said Mark Ledger-Evans, Asia-focused emerging markets fixed-income portfolio manager at Ninety One.
“It can be solved relatively easily because I think this has been self-inflicted,” said Ledger-Evans, who has been neutral to underweight Indonesian bonds and the rupiah. “We weren’t here three years ago.”
The rupiah hit a record low of 18,285 per US dollar on Tuesday and is down 8.7% this year, making it Asia’s worst-performing currency. The yield on the benchmark 10-year note is at 7.6%, not far from a six-year high hit earlier this month.
For bond investors, the money is in the carry, the yield advantage over developed markets, but a fast-weakening currency erodes much of the gain.
MSCI’S THREAT LOOMS LARGE
Indonesia’s annus horribilis started with the January warning from MSCI, while outlook cuts by rating agencies Moody’s and Fitch and the sudden departure of the central bank governor later in the year added to investor anxiety.
The country has until the middle of 2027 to retain its emerging-market status, keeping it open to index-tracking funds and active funds. Authorities have announced measures to avoid any downgrade, including investigations into suspected coordinated trading.
“It’s a local issue that’s now bubbled up into a global problem,” said Alex Matturri, former CEO of S&P Dow Jones Indices, who called the two-step downgrade “pretty harsh” for a country of Indonesia’s size.
Foreign investors have already pulled $5.36 billion from Indonesian equities this year and the benchmark index is down 38%. Goldman Sachs estimates an MSCI removal could spur another $5.6 billion of passive outflows.
Not everyone is selling. The broader macro picture, some investors say, shows few signs of the strains, with the economy growing faster than expected in the third quarter.
Christopher Beselin, founding partner at Endurance Capital, called Indonesia “the easiest buy among emerging markets right now,” citing a disconnect between company fundamentals and valuations.
But the immediate focus is the rupiah. If consumers feel the pain of a sliding currency, especially as war in the Middle East lifts energy prices, there could be economic and political fallout.
“This is an extremely serious issue,” Hashim Djojohadikusumo, Prabowo’s brother and a businessman, said last month. “We must not let the rupiah reach 21,000 or 22,000 a dollar. This would have an extraordinarily negative political impact.”
(Reporting by Ankur Banerjee in Singapore and Stefanno Sulaiman in Jakarta; Editing by John Mair)

